The Lesbian Take
Be part of the movement to rebuild authentic Lesbian community and media. On this podcast, we say what many lesbians know but are terrified of voicing. Our aim is to address lesbian issues and subjects that matter to us.
The Lesbian Take
Cornell Seven Lawsuit and What Lesbians Can Learn About the Moving Goalpost of Consent
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
This is the Lesbian Take on the recent controversy surrounding the Cornell Seven, which sparked intense discussions across social media platforms. This case, which involves a lawsuit filed by a former Cornell student under the alias Jane Doe, brings to light critical issues surrounding consent and the societal pressures surrounding it.
Be part of the movement to rebuild authentic lesbian community and media. Leave us a review and subscribe for new episodes. Every rating/review helps our mission.
And for more about MC check out her books HERE
So if you haven't been sitting under a rock, you've probably heard of the Cornell 7, the latest controversy spurring internet mobs to action. I'll summarize this issue before diving into my lesbian take because, yes, I do think there is a lot that lesbians can take away from this tragic case, specifically around consent. So what happened? Recently, a lawsuit was filed under the alias Jane Doe, who is a former female university student of Cornell. And Doe alleged that she was gang raped at a fraternity house back in 2024, which has prompted the reopening of an investigation. But her case also unleashed a chaotic firestorm on social media, which featured the usual suspects, so the virtue signalers, the rage amplifiers, the context strippers, the moral accountants, the amateur detectives, and of course the misogynists. Yes, the mob has been activated. And what's important to remember here is that the mob doesn't care about principles of justice like procedural fairness and due process. All it cares about is being heard. So that is where we're at. A suit has been filed, an investigation has been reopened, and the mob is doing what it does best, publishing the names of everybody involved and ruining their lives. Me, I don't know what happened, but I do have opinions. I'm more inclined to side with Jane Doe because I think that upon review of all the information I have, I don't think that Cornell took all the appropriate steps to ensure that Doe's accusations were appropriately investigated. But also, we're so early in this case, like this new case, that I don't really think my opinion matters. And before I can properly come to a determination, I believe in going through the process, however flawed it may be, before rendering a guilty or innocent verdict. To me, facts matter. And I really want to see the world move back to a place where we try to understand as much as possible before succumbing to outrage. But let's rewind the clock. I want to take you through what we know happened. And so we'll start with on or around October 19th, 2024. Jane Doe was 20 years old. She was drinking vodka at her sorority house. And when she left for a bar, she was already intoxicated. At the bar, she was served more alcohol. And then around 11 p.m., she says that she was well and truly intoxicated and probably consumed roughly 10 standard drinks in a span of three hours. And this was around the time that she arrived at Chi Fi Fraternity House to meet up with a friend. And this friend has been named as a defendant in the case. So she meets up with this friend at the fraternity house. He gives her a beer and then proposes that Doe engages in a threesome. Doe consented. She says that she consented to this threesome, and she was taken to another room in the house. And there the friend and the other party to the threesome pressured her to snort what they told her was ketamine, and they gave her even more alcohol. And so this is going on. Doe says that she was pretty okay with the aspects of the initial encounter, but she didn't consent to and was incapable of consenting to what later evolved into sexual encounters with multiple members of the fraternity. So that's something that came out in this case and really outraged the internet. And Doe says that at one point there were seven men in the room with her, and it is alleged that they poured ketamine all over her body and snorted it. Around 5 45 a.m., Doe states that she lost consciousness. And so that is sort of the incident. Over the weeks that ensued, Doe came to the realization that what happened to her was rape. And so she reported it to Cornell University Police on November 8th, 2024. And this resulted in Chi Fi, so that fraternity chapter being placed on a suspension. Doe told the police that she had become extremely uncomfortable with how the night turned out and thought that, you know, if I pass out and men had sex with me, then they should be charged with rape. Doe was asked to sign a statement which omitted, okay, so it didn't have it in it, omitted her accusation of rape, and it is because of that omission that the county police department decided not to press charges. Meanwhile, the university investigation was still ongoing. Four of the fraternity members acknowledged having sexual contact with Doe, but said that the interactions were consensual. Others denied participating in sexual encounters and said Doe didn't seem intoxicated. Anyhow, Cornell has been in the hot seat ever since Jane Doe filed her new lawsuit because the internet mob believes that nothing substantial came out of its investigation. Now, when I first heard of the story, I was told that the boys got a slap on the wrist and they were asked to write an essay. So that's what I heard. And I was like, that seems a little odd. But Cornell recently released a statement basically saying that the university issued a range of sanctions, which included expulsions and suspensions, and none of the individuals charged were offered the opportunity to write essays as the sole consequence, and that any suggestions that the university did not impose consequential punishments is false. So Cornell has taken the position that they did act and they did act appropriately. So that's the summary of this case in a nutshell. More information has come out through some texts between the complainant and one of the defendants, so the friend. So that's in a text message that she sent to him. So these texts may add a layer of complexity to the case, but at the same time, I think that it's reflective of the standard trauma response. So we will see what happens. My take on this is that I totally understand public outrage. You know, even me when I was I was told, like I didn't have all the information. Someone told me, hey, like they just got a slap on the wrist. I I was a little annoyed, right? But then I looked into it more, and I think that's important. But I do really think that if there's anyone to be angry at, I think we really need to start pointing the fingers at ourselves, right? Because women and girls, from the moment we are born into this world, we are bombarded with messaging that tells us and makes us hesitant to say no and erect boundaries. This messaging tells us that we need to protect the men who hurt us. This messaging, it tells us that we need to be caring. It is also telling us that, you know, the expectation that we need to be cared for is way too much. Because seriously, think of it this way, if the positions were flipped, if it was a young man who drank way too much and took ketamine and he was at a sorority, the outcome would be so different. The sorority sisters would set him up somewhere safe while he came down. But a woman in the same situation would be held responsible for getting way too drunk, and women were also told you deserve it. But let's get one thing straight. Rape it happens because rapist rape. It's not because a woman's skirt is too short or that she was drunk. And society and the messages we give to women is that it's your fault. If some somebody does something to you that is wrong, it's your fault somehow. And now we also need to factor in the knowledge that yes doesn't mean yes. Women say they consent to things they do not want to do all the time. Because we've been trained from a very young age that our boundaries are negotiable. It's been whipped into us that no isn't okay, and that if we aren't flexible, there will be repercussions. And so sometimes the process of establishing a boundary is more punishment than simply giving in to what we know in our hearts of hearts is wrong. And so this dovetails into what I want to do and bring it back to lesbians because right now many lesbians, especially the younger generation, they are Jin Doe. These young lesbians, they know that they are not attracted to the opposite sex. But the messaging they are being given is that they are same-gender attracted, which is a fallacy. The fact is that they're exclusively same-sex attracted. If you're a lesbian, you're exclusively same-sex attracted. And there's also bisexual women who have a significant preference for women too, and they are not interested in engaging with the opposite sex in any form romantically or physically. But the message we are given is that we're attracted to gender. That's not the that's not the case. We're attracted to bodies. And so what I could say about lesbians who erect boundaries and say no to this modern homophobia is that we're bullied, we're assaulted, we're threatened, and in even some cases, we have been murdered. Okay, go Google Mitchfest. Okay, look at the lesbian couple who was murdered. Why for saying no? And I can speak on this personally. I have very clear boundaries. Me, previously, I had no problem coexisting with males who identified as women who wanted to be in lesbian spaces. Because back in my day, there were very few of them, and they knew that they weren't lesbians, and they knew that lesbians were not interested in them and they didn't pursue us, right? Or if they did, I just wasn't aware of it. But in recent years, the goalpost has moved, and too many lesbians have caved into the pressure to consent to the erasure of who and what we are to make space in our label for those who really do not belong and have no place there. And this has resulted in a lot of lesbians saying yes to sexual encounters that they do not want with the opposite sex, which is traumatizing for them. I have come across videos of lesbians crying about what has happened to them. I have heard accounts of lesbians telling these men no over and over and over, and then facing backlash and bullying until they caved and consented. But that is not consent. That is not yes, that is coercion, that is rape culture. So where am I going with this? There will continue to be Jane Does so long as women continue to treat our boundaries as something to be negotiated with. We need to draw a line in the sand, and when that line is crossed, we need to be firm and ensure that those who cross it no consequences. It starts with messaging and it needs to start young because right now, more than ever, society is failing girls and young women. All across Western nations, we see women having to do all this rework to have the law re-establish that we are our embodiment and that our class needs protections. But in the interim, it is the younger generation who is being taught that they cannot say no and that, you know, they need to consent. And if they consent to one thing, that means they consent to everything. And it's ridiculous, right? We have a consent problem because yes doesn't mean yes. A lot of women just go with what we're told we need to do, even though we really, really don't want to. All women struggle in this area. And frankly, until we do better and work together to protect our own interests, nothing will change. With respect to the Jane Doe case, I will continue to follow it. And it's my hope that there's an outcome that moves women closer to uniting in our efforts to stamp out the systemic misogyny that feeds our agreeableness because I'm fed up with our good nature being taken advantage of. Because at the end of the day, maybe she was okay with the threesome, but how the hell did that go, that goalpost move to seven men in a room? How the hell did with lesbians did it get to hey, like we're cool if you want to be our friends to oh, you're a lesbian too, even though you're not fucking a female? Like, give me a fucking break, man. I'm fed up with the nonsense. Women continue to be taken advantage of, and it's just so fucking annoying. Anyways, I'm gonna go to my personal updates. So, guys, I have finished the first draft of Level Up Lex, which is super exciting, and now I'm rewriting pretty much all of it because that's my writing process. I am what is known as a discovery writer. Or George R.R. Martin likes to say, like gardener, like there's architects and gardeners. So architects they lay everything out first, like they build a plan, while gardeners they just sort of like sprinkle seeds and then they see what like pops up. I'm a gardener, okay? And I don't plot. As I write, I get better ideas. And so now with the second draft, I have to go back in, fill the plot holes, and also polish over all the bits that don't make sense in the context of what the story needs to be. So that's my process. And for those of you who are Born of Blood and Magic fans, I also have an update. Recently I re-listened to Born of Blood and Magic, you know, by Laura Horwitz. If you haven't listened to the audiobook, listen to the audiobook. It's so good. I was just like, wow, I wrote this. Like sometimes I just can't believe that I wrote it because it's so good. Uh Bobam is everything that I love. Enemies, lovers, detailed world building, a plot that's unpredictably predictable, and a cast who just feels so real that you know them. But I know that everybody wanted a third spicy scene. So good news is that I actually have finally started typing out a spicy scene for the end. And that new spicy scene will be inserted in the special edition of Born of Blood and Magic that I'm thinking will only be available for purchase on my website when I get around to that. But I'm hoping to release that special edition at the end of the year, like Christmas time. So I'm super stoked for that. I also want to say like a big thank you to the Lesbian Take listeners for tuning in week after week. Uh, the Lesbian Take is taking off a lot faster than my previous podcast, a very savvy podcast. Like I've already hit a thousand downloads, which I get it, is like, oh, a thousand downloads, that's not that much. But for a podcast, that's colossal. So I just want to say thank you. You know, I'm trying to build a community here. Lesbian media, you know, talk about issues that matter to lesbians. So, you know, I hope you keep tuning in and remember to subscribe so you get new episodes as they come out. And every single rating really does help others find this podcast. So uh leave a rating or a review, really appreciate that. And stay loud, stay proud, and we'll talk soon.
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Lesbian Project Podcast
The Lesbian Project Podcast
Sex Matters
Sex Matters