The Lesbian Take
Be part of the movement to rebuild authentic Lesbian community and media. On this podcast, we say what many lesbians know but are terrified of voicing. Our aim is to address lesbian issues and subjects that matter to us.
The Lesbian Take
The Cult of Nice is Killing Lesbian Spaces
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
What's killing lesbian spaces? The cult of nice. MC is joined by Carol from the Peak Lesbian podcast for a no-BS conversation about performative inclusivity, disappearing boundaries, and why communities fall apart when they're afraid to say who they're for. If everything is for everyone, is it really for anyone?
Be part of the movement to rebuild authentic lesbian community and media. Leave us a review and subscribe for new episodes. Every rating/review helps our mission.
And for more about MC check out her books HERE
Hi, hi I'm Cyril. How are you?
SPEAKER_01Good, good. I'm glad to be back talking with you.
SPEAKER_00I I really enjoyed our last few conversations. You know?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I'm I'm happy to have a little joint venture here. What are we what are we talking about today? We are going to be talking about lesbian spaces, basically, and why that's important to us and what we think about the current state of it and all that good stuff.
SPEAKER_00It's something I'm very passionate about, uh as you know. Yeah, which is it's why you started your podcast, right? It's why I changed my last podcast because I I used to have a podcast called a very sapphic podcast. And we were reviewing a lot of books on there and interviewing a lot of Sapphic authors. And I just started getting really frustrated with Sapphic because historically that meant lesbian, right? And it is one of those terms, like many terms right now, that are just being revised to mean anything and everything. And it's very annoying. And I started to be a little annoyed with the fact that, okay, what if I just want lesbian? What if I I just want to know when I pick up a book or if uh I'm watching a show that it's actually lesbians, not not by not pan, not queer, not nothing, lesbian. So a homosexual woman and another homosexual woman, what if I just want that?
SPEAKER_01Because because sapphic has become a catch-all in a lot of ways. So what what were you seeing in Sapphic stuff that you didn't want to see? They just didn't read gay.
SPEAKER_00That's my own.
SPEAKER_01Were there men involved?
SPEAKER_00That's the other thing, is sometimes they'll say, Oh, this book is sapphic, and then no Because it has a bisexual woman who fucks around. There it has a bisexual woman who fucks around with only men, but maybe she has feelings for the girl. Yeah. But they're calling this sapphic, and I'm just like, Where the hell in this book? For example, A Dowry of Blood. Really amazing book. Mind you, I think it's a really amazing book, but it has nothing to do with women fucking women.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. So, but your purpose for the podcast was what was your main purpose for starting this this year podcast now?
SPEAKER_00I wanted lesbian-specific content. I decided we need to have lesbian media, media that is for lesbians, by lesbians, lesbians who seriously are actually lesbians and we're not caught up in all of the bullshit that's homophobic. Because there's a lot of this modern bullshit, homophobic stuff that's going on. And I don't know about you, but I have a lot of lesbian friends, and it's like we all agree about the same things, but we've just been so force-teamed into this broader group that I think we just think we can't say anything about it.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I I started the podcast for the same reason. I wanted um lesbian focused, specific media or podcast. And, you know, I like podcasts. I listen to a bunch of different podcasts and usually paranormal ones, uh, but still I enjoy podcasts. And I was looking for, I was I went through a phase of looking for lesbian podcasts, you know? And I found some, but they they were discontinued. They were no longer doing anything. They were from four or five years ago. And in all the new ones were all labeled as queer and which I don't like the term, so already that kind of turns me off. But queer is in they included everybody. So it wasn't lesbian specific. It was just there would be women who were lesbians, there were women who were bisexual, and there was men who identified as women and identified as lesbians, included in that. And I'm just like, this is not my jam, you know, like, and I take the position that it's cool if that's your jam, if you like that, if you're a woman who's into women and you want all this, you like all this inclusion, more power to you, great. But I just would like the same amount of respect for women like myself who don't, who want very specific, focused spaces, groups, and content to lesbians, and um, you know, give us the space to have our own groups as well, without calling us bigots or transphobic or homophobic or misogynistic. I've had all those thrown at me, which is hilarious. But yeah, you're just like and I know like people will say what people want to say, but I feel like it'd be nice if society kind of a progressivist society, I think should respect boundaries. And I think should respect that uh each group of people, each group of my uh each a minority group has a unique history, has a unique culture, and they should have the right to create that group and have the boundaries respected. Because a tr a trans woman's experience is a very different experience than a lesbian woman's experience, right? And in a way, by including all of them together, you're erasing both. I think it's I think it's I think it's cruel to erase what you know a male individual who decides to, you know, transition and try to live as a woman, what his experience has been like with that. His experience is not my experience. I'll never understand it, and he'll never understand my experience, and that's okay. But because we have such different experiences, because he is male, regardless of how he identifies or lives his life, he's still male. I don't want males in my spaces. If I have a lesbian space, I don't want males there. That that is just the way it is.
SPEAKER_00I agree. What I could say is when I was deep into the party circuit, right? I used to go out a lot. I still to this day remember the very first time a male was in one of these spaces. And everybody was on ease. There was like a circle of space around this individual, right? And you know, where I went was Mel, like you're like, I started chastising myself. I was like, Mel, like, you know, you should be a little empathetic, you know, you shouldn't be judging, you know. But I also was like, this person doesn't belong here. Like, why would somebody come to a space where they know they're not gonna make a connection? So that also was a question that I was thinking about for myself, but there was a big circle around them.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And it's funny, you you went right to interrogating yourself about your sensitivity when the question should have been completely flipped right away. What is wrong with him? What's wrong with him that he's not respecting this space? I think it's just so rude to not, and it I think it's just a an unwillingness to, I think, have the bravery to accept your reality. And the reality is as a as a trans person, you will never be the opposite sex. You try to live, you try to live as the opposite sex, you try to appear as the opposite sex as much as you can, but you will never be the opposite sex. And there is realities that come with that. And I think that is for you to manage and deal with, with hopefully the help of maybe a good therapist or something, and how you kind of create congruence in an incongruent existence. Yeah. And I know this for I know this from personal experience. It's like, for all intents and purposes, I think I pass pretty well. That doesn't change me. It doesn't change my history, doesn't change my lived experience as a woman, the way I was socialized, the way my biology works. It's just, it's so different. You cannot, you cannot throw that away. There's so many levels to it.
SPEAKER_00Socialization starts young. And so, and I'm seeing this because I have a little nephew right now. And from the moment he was like even just like a six-month-old, right? But now he's a toddler and getting up to no good. And you should hear what everybody says. Oh, he's just a boy, boys will be boys, like, you know, don't don't yell at him for doing that. He's just he's just a boy. This is just how boys are. So I he's not even, he's not even like five years old. Like the messaging starts very young. And little girls are given different messaging. So, you know, if a little girl is acting like this, they're probably gonna be like, young ladies don't do this. No, no, they're probably gonna be harsher on on a on a toddler who's a girl who's acting like a young boy. It starts very early. So this idea that your experience, you could know the experience of the opposite sex is completely false. A male will never have a single female thought, and a female will never have a single male thought. I agree. It's impossible. Yeah, it's it's factually impossible. It's impossible. You cannot know what the other sex is feeling because that is not you. We are our embodiment. I really and truly believe that, and everything else is just social socialization, right? So, you know, and I think what true progressivism is, progressivism, can I pronounce that three times fast? Progressivism, liberalism is letting everybody just do whatever they want so long we have our our tenant laws and everything, everybody has to abide the law, but you should be able to dress how you want, act how you want, have jobs that you want, and it shouldn't matter. And I think that is what is actually progress and what is a liberal. But the moment we start to slap stereotypes on people and being like, hey, no, you can't be a woman because you have that type of job, or you can't be a woman if you actually think that you can express your opinion loudly. You can't be a woman if you park well. Like the list goes on and on. Yeah, I just so it's just very different. And the lesbian experience is so unique because if you're you're actually a lesbian, if you're actually a homosexual woman, you're apathetic to men. And we live in a world that's all about men, right? I have some guy friends or whatever, but I don't think about them. And if they're not around, I don't think about them. Almost everything, my whole world centers around women. Men, they they might as well not exist. And I think that's a very lesbian experience. And so if you're not a lesbian, you really, really, really can't understand what the lesbian experience is. And it is like coming home when you meet other lesbians who know what you've been through and you can actually relate because for a very long time it can feel like you're so alone. And I think that that is why it's so important to have spaces with people who have gone through the shit that you've gone through.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And again, that goes back to, you know, as a person who is a minority in in a huge majority. You spend a lot of your life. I mean, even it starts when you're a kid. I for most of us. I mean, I felt different as a kid. I felt somehow like I wasn't, I didn't belong. And I I always felt like I just didn't belong with the girls, but I didn't belong with the boys. It was just weird space to be in. And uh, you know, you you go this whole, this whole time just feeling kind of an outsider. And then when your sexuality comes into it in your teens or whatever, you're just like, oh my God, and that's a whole to-do. And then when you finally come out and you go, like, I'm, you know, when I finally came out and I went to my first like youth group and met other lesbians and other just gay people, and then started going to clubs and hanging out with lesbians, it was just like coming home. It really was. It was so awesome to be around people that were like me, that I could be myself around and not only just be myself, but they thought I was cool. They thought I was beautiful, they thought all these things that I never got in the straight world. I never got, you know, I I occasionally got you have a good body when I was starving myself, which is hilarious. But, you know, I occasionally got, oh, you have a good body, but never got really much that you're gorgeous, you're pretty, you're awesome, you're just you're a beautiful woman. And especially when you're butch, you don't get that. Uh but then when I got into the lesbian community, there were lesbians that thought I was a beautiful woman. My wife's one of them. And that's, you know, that's uh that's that's a real magical thing. So as an older lesbian, I I have mourned the loss of lesbian spaces like that. And I've mourned the loss of the social contract where people understood that lesbians should have their own spaces and be respected. Like when I was, you know, when I first came out in the early 2000s and it was still brick and mortar clubs and stuff like that, they were all just gay clubs. Everybody went pretty much, you know. But even the gay men and the lesbians, they did kind of their own thing. Like we were friends and stuff sometimes, but the gay men generally respected the lesbian space and lesbians respected the gay men's space. Well, that's gay men stuff over there. That's lesbian stuff over there, you know? And I just I missed that social contract of respecting people's boundaries and respecting people's spaces and understanding when you didn't fucking belong.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. And I can't speak to the US because it seems like what I've been experiencing here in Canada has just been sort of rapid onset. But it seems like, especially in California, this bullshit has been happening for decades where like lesbian spaces have sort of not become lesbian spaces. And I wonder if that also goes back to why all these lesbian spaces are closing down. Because to be honest, do I want to go to a queer space? No, I want to go to a lesbian space.
SPEAKER_01Not unless the queer not unless the queer space is for lesbians only. You can call it whatever the fuck you want.
SPEAKER_00I don't think I don't think if you're calling it queer, it is a lesbian space. I don't think the two can coexist. I don't think that if you're fine calling your bar a queer space, I don't think you would actually have it be a lesbian space.
SPEAKER_01Because the moment is that the Yeah, I don't think so either, not the way, not the way it's used, but I'm just I'm plain devil's advocate here. Yeah. I don't like the I don't like the word queer. However, it's used so much now that let's say hypothetically that there was a s a lesbian bar that was used the word queer. If it was in fact a lesbian bar, I would still go. I would be like, okay, look, I don't like the word, but at least we are actually all queers here. Do you know what I mean? That's the point.
SPEAKER_00I like I think the queer word though would throw me off and I wouldn't even check because queer. Queer would flag is a queer has been a flag to me that it's not a safe space for homosexuals.
SPEAKER_01I get that. But I have heard from a lot of younger lesbians where this queer is used so the queer community, it's used so much that now they they really, you know, I get it. I thought so I totally get it.
SPEAKER_00I totally get it, Carol. I'm with you.
SPEAKER_01I would also be like, eh.
SPEAKER_00I was this lesbian a year ago. I was fine with the word queer. Anyone who like reads any of my books will see the word like I cringe now when I see it. Like I have a visceral reaction to the word queer because I know too much. I didn't I didn't have an understanding of why that word and why that ideology was problematic. Now that I know, I just equate queer with homophobia. And it's I might like my problem with queer is twofold.
SPEAKER_01And one is I I think back in the day there were some gay people who would call themselves queer, or it was more in a joking way, though. Or you'd be like, walk, I remember walking into the club one time and seeing some of my gay guy friends hanging out, and I'm like, hey, queers, what's up? Ha ha ha ha. You know, because that it was a slur. And no person could actually use that was, but we use it with each other as like a joking thing, right? So I've used the term in that way as a reclaiming of the slur, as lots of minority groups do. So I don't really have a problem with it so much like that. I have a problem with it, people using the word queer to label themselves who are not homosexual. That's a problem because it's like, wait a minute, you're queer. What is and and then the second part of that is queers become all-inclusive.
SPEAKER_00It's an umbrella for everybody. It's an umbrella term.
SPEAKER_01It means it means nothing. Actually, actually, it does mean something now. It means freak. It means the original meaning of the fucking word. We've gone full circle back to the original meaning.
SPEAKER_00Maybe that's why I really hate it, because it it does mean I'm not a freak. I'm normal. I'm just a homosexual.
SPEAKER_01That's it. Wasn't that the whole fucking purpose of gay liberation? Wasn't that the whole fucking purpose was to become part of the community and become seen as normal and not a freak and not a queer and not some outsider? And it's like now it's gone, like, in my opinion, gone right back, right back to the whole, you know, people are like self-segregating themselves out and trying to be special in some way. And I'm like, that's a sign of a lot of privilege when you can try to be special by calling yourself queer. When not to sound like an old person, but back when I was young, I wouldn't hear queer unless someone was being aggressive and hated me. That's when I heard queer usually. Yeah. So that pisses me off that it's used. Oh my God, the fact that it's used to mean the whole community enrages me. I don't want to be called queer. Don't call me queer. Don't call me queer. It's offensive. And why, why is, why is my opinion not valued? That's the other thing. Why are some people's opinions okay and other people's not? Why are my feelings less important than someone else's feelings? Because anytime I've brought up the whole to people who use the word queer, anytime I've brought up the idea that I don't like it because it's a slur, well, that's not how it's used now. So you just need to get over it.
SPEAKER_00Well, now fuck you. Yeah, but then they they will be like, you have to call me this because otherwise, like, you know, you're gonna hurt my feelings. Like, you know, it's so hypocritical, right? It's like you will say, Don't call me this, and it's like the world's on fire. What do you mean I can't call you this? And then they will tell you, you have to call me Zer. And it's like, just wait, wait a second here. You're insisting that you're you can call me queer, and you expect me to call you what?
SPEAKER_01Like, yeah, I I would like everybody to just respect to respect everybody's labels if they want to go that way. That's fine. But be conscious of that. Don't use don't just because you use a label, don't broadly use it for everybody else and then get mad at the other people when they say they don't want it used.
SPEAKER_00It's so hypocritical. They've mainstreamed a word that it can now be appropriated by people who are not homosexuals or not attracted to the same sex. They've appropriated this, this word, and it is a slur. Like this word is probably similar to the the faggot, right? I see it on the same level as faggot, but we don't use that. So why why is it now? Can you imagine? Why is it that now queer is okay, and we can even have heterosexuals calling themselves queer and calling gay people queer. And in my opinion, it's just as bad of a word as faggot.
SPEAKER_01It it would be like it, it's in my in my opinion, it's like the N-word, right? Yeah. A lot of a lot of black folks use that with them with themselves and among themselves, but white people fucking know you don't use that word. Everybody understands how that works, right? It would be like if suddenly all everybody decided that that was gonna be the word we use now for this group. We're gonna use the N-word for this group.
SPEAKER_00Like, what that is literally what has happened. That's like, in my opinion, it's either you read out every single fucking letter in that acronym or leave lesbians out of it. Like, I don't even want to be part of that acronym. I flinch every time on the news when they're like, this is against LGBTQ rights. And I'm just like, what the hell does any of this have to do with lesbian? None, everything for the last five years, every single time. They talk about LGBTQ plus rights, nothing that they think is is is a right is a right for lesbians or something that is actually of interest to lesbians. If anything, it's harming lesbians.
SPEAKER_01It just I want the LL. Talk let's talk about critical thinking. That it's that's I really am very upset that our society has lost all ability to critically think and to have discussions around hot topic issues or hot button issues that enrage some people and make us frustrated, but we can't seem to have conversations about them. We just res resolve, like we just dissolve into hurling names at each other or violence. And it's just obnoxious. It's really obnoxious. But like, why can't we have conversations about this? It's so frustrating.
SPEAKER_00It's extremely frustrating. It's because the approach that they're taking is a no-debate approach. Because the moment is a big red flag. The moment, the moment you people have been trying to debate this for years, but the approach has been a no-debate approach because the moment you start to actually talk about the issues, like this is probably the only movement that the more you learn about it, the less you support it. And I think that is why it is a no-debate approach. Yeah. That they're a very hardline no debate.
SPEAKER_01Well, there's and there's there's a big problem with using LGBTQ people because that is what people? Who people are we talking about here? That's a lot of that's a lot of different people in one group.
SPEAKER_00And I have a problem with this plus. What does plus mean? Like, I mean, I have some ideas what this plus means, and it's all types of fetishes and all types of stuff. And it's like, what the hell does that have to do with my sexuality as a homosexual woman? Like, I'm so sorry, but no, I'm not a freak. I'm not not normal. I just happen to be a fucking homosexual. That's literally it. And I I want to live my life, a normal life. And I don't want me being a lesbian being my whole personality and how everybody perceived me. And I think that is the initial goal. That was the initial goal of lesbians and gay people, is just that we just want to live our lives and be left alone. But this new movement, this queer movement, is about see me, affirm me, I am special. You have to recognize I'm special. And I just think that is completely different than what lesbians and gay men were fighting for for decades. Yeah. If that makes sense. And I I I think that is why it's important to go back to having lesbian spaces because if I think if we had more spaces that were very clear, hey, look, like this is a lesbian space, like or a lesbian event, just lesbians female only, people are gonna flock to find that group. I find a lot of people out of like right now, out of I'm getting a lot of messages off the side, like, hey, like even in Toronto, like you want to have a meetup or whatever. People are trying to find community, like real community. I think they would.
SPEAKER_01The problem is, is having a lesbian-only group and enforcing the boundaries that are necessary to enforce now, because it used to be we didn't really have to enforce boundaries too much. It would generally be respected. Now we have to actually hardline enforce boundaries. We have to go, lesbian only means female homosexual. It means no trans identified men. It means no trans women. And the minute you say no trans women, that's where you lose it.
SPEAKER_00No one because But who wants, like, I'm gonna be honest, if that is your opinion, if you're a lesbian who is basically a homophobe, but that's basically how I see it. Is if you're a lesbian who's a homophobe, I'm sorry, you don't belong in the lesbian group chat. So I think it's that's how I view it, is that like if I get homophob, like there's a lot of lesbians who it's not like they're probably just not as educated on the topic as I am. And there's they're people who are empathetic, but they also see the value in female only spaces, right? So I think if you're somebody who's empathetic to the cause and maybe we don't agree on everything, I have so many lesbian friends, we don't agree on everything, but we would like to have a female only space, a lesbian-only, female-only space.
SPEAKER_01The problem is this idea of having a female only space has been equated with bigotry now. And no one wants to talk about how that's bigotry. No one wants to talk about is that really bigotry? They just they just throw out, they just throw it out. Oh, you're being transphobic. They throw out transphobia, bigotry, transphobia, bigotry, and just we need to cuss the conversation. There's no more conversation.
SPEAKER_00We need to start throwing it back at them though. You are being homophobic. That space is.
SPEAKER_01Well, actually, what she said was she didn't understand why a having a male-identified or a trans identified male in a female only space was any different than having a lesbian there. Sounds very homophobic to me. And I told her that's the most that's that's the most homophobic thing I've heard in quite a long time. She was she just sh her flabers were gasted, she couldn't understand.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. I was actually listening to a podcast, I don't know if it was Sex Matters or something. And they were talking about the hate bill or the no-conversion therapy bill in Canada. And what I found very interesting was that TK Plus used the gay man and they included gender ideology or gender identity into the hate bill. But this affirmation model they're pushing is actually, in my opinion, the modern day version of conversion therapy for gay people. And so that is something that a year later he was seeing. He was like, oh my God, the bill that I push forward because I was subjected to gay conversion therapy is now resulting in a lot of gay men who are perhaps feminine, feminine gay men undergoing conversion therapy.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_01I mean, I've I've honestly personally, I've thought for many years now that the that trans ideology primarily is a form of conversion therapy for gay people. I think overall the ideology is is is really hard on gay people because it it rests on the idea that that you have a gender and in order to get across what your gender is, there's some there's some performing you're doing, or there's some there's these stereotypes. It relies on stereotypes. And as we all know, very many gay people meet those stereotypes. A lot of gay men are feminine or would be considered feminine acting. A lot of lesbians would be considered masculine, masculine acting or presenting, or however you want to word it, right? And from a very young age, like one of the big trans tap talking points, and I remember this, is oh, I've on I was four years old, I didn't want to wear a dress. I knew I was a boy then. Well, that did lots of four-year-olds don't want to wear dresses. There's lots of reasons girls don't want to wear dresses. And guess guess who really never wanted to wear dresses? A lot of fucking lesbians.
SPEAKER_00I didn't have a dress. A lot of Butch lesbians never wanted to wear dresses. You put me in a dress, I cried. Like it it wasn't even just a dress. Like if I had like a feminine hairstyle, I would cry. Like or want to cry. I didn't like it because it didn't match how I saw myself. So I didn't like it. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01But there's so much overlap between what makes a kid trans or a person trans and the way gay people are that you know, and no one wants to talk about that. No one wants to talk about how do you pull those apart? If you can, how do you? How do you actually diagnose trans in somebody? What is the diagnosing criteria? When you look at the diagnosing criteria, it's it's stereotypes. And it's and it's it's re-traumatizing people who are already traumatized, right? Because obviously if you hate your body or you want to change your sex, something's wrong. You've got something going on, but they're just telling you, oh no, you're right, your body's wrong. Yeah, I don't know.
SPEAKER_00I think that that's why it's an adult decision. That's why I'm like, it's an adult decision. I don't care what an adult wants to do. You wanna do whatever, you know. Like I'm somebody, I have tattoos and piercings and all types of stuff. Because that's just how I want to look. So the way I see it is if you tell you just want to look.
SPEAKER_01But did you go into the therapist and say you were depressed and and she said, get some tattoos and you'll feel better, even though you didn't maybe maybe you were a woman, you didn't want to get tattoos, but they were like, Well, if you get tattoos, you'll feel better. And you're like, Okay, I'll get the tattoos. No, I mean that's what's happening. I understand the therapy part of it, that's what's happening. People, adults too, are going into therapists and saying, basically going, I have gender dysphoria. And the answer from the therapist is not to question at all. The answer to the therapist is you must be trans. And they help you to find your transness. And then they tell you that the surgeries are going to make you feel better. And when they don't, then what?
SPEAKER_00Well, I think we just have to wait and see. I think there's a lot of law, I think there's a lot of lawsuits coming because I think that therapy is Well, not for adults there isn't, but for the kids there is, which is good. I think therapy is failing. Psychologists, associations, and whatever, they've been overtaken by activists. The way I see it, when you're a doctor, your whole mandate is to do no harm. And a lot of harm is happening. And so I don't know, they're gonna have to shape up, or that profession is gonna be completely trashed, and nobody's gonna go to therapy and they're we're all gonna just use Chat GPT.
SPEAKER_01Well, there's yeah, I think at this point you might be better with Chat GPT with post-therapist. But I guess to to bring it back around, it's the critical thinking part, right? Again, this is there's a lack of critical thinking here. There's a lack of asking why. There's a lack of willingness to sit with a hard question and discuss it and not automatically recoil because you have an emotional response. Like when I was in school, um, I was a philosophy major, and one of my classes was all about what is knowledge, and then how do you know what you know? It really was about picking that apart. And one thing my my instructor said that I that really changed my whole kind of perspective was when you're having a conversation about something and you feel a physical response, whether it's agitation, aggression, anger, that's a key to slow down, to stop, and to try to engage your logical mind to work through the problem. And, you know, and I know therapy also teaches this kind of way of doing things too. And I think that that's what critical thinking is. It's stopping that automatic visceral response and going, okay, why am I having this response? Dude, what they said, does it make sense? How can I argue for my side? What does my side have to offer that is actually more logical or has more truth to it than the other side does? No one does that anymore. Everybody just goes, fuck you, man, you're a bigot. Well, fuck you, hippie, you're woke. And then that's the end of it.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think the true marker of intelligence is the ability to change your mind. Like based on it's okay to change your mind. That's how my mind works, is that as information comes in, my opinion changes, right? So, like, if I get some some new information, like an actual real scientific study, like a real one that has been peer-reviewed and has been tried and tested another time, and it actually supports, you know, that this group is the most marginalized and everything and everything, and they will commit suicide if they aren't granted A, B, C, D, E, F, G. If we actually get real scientific papers that have been replicated and using the scientific method, if we actually had real facts and everything, maybe my mind would change a little. Like, you know, I'm somebody that as new information comes in, I review it. And I I I am also somebody I I question myself. I'm like, am I actually wrong about this? Or am I right about this? Like, what I could say though is I think that I'm open, I'm somebody who's open enough to say, I don't know.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's okay to say you don't know. It's it's okay to say, I don't know enough. I do that a lot. I go, yeah, this is my opinion generally on this topic, but I haven't read exactly what you're what you're laying down. So I can't, I'm not gonna actually go off on it because I don't know. I haven't read it myself. It's the same way with people who get up in arms about different legislative bills and shit, and they never read them. And it's so easy to read them. You just go, you get access and read them. I've read so many myself and come away going, I think they're being a little overly dramatic about this. I don't know if this is actually as serious as they think it is. And I know there was, I was asked to, I was thinking it was about a year ago now, I was asked to, as a detransitioner, to come out and, you know, speak against this California bill that was going through. And I said, well, as my policy is to always read the bill myself and to make my own conclusion and see if I'm going to support or not support or say anything at all. So I read the bill myself and I it didn't quite, in my opinion, did sound and say what they were thinking it was saying. And I didn't really agree with their takeaway. And I was like, I don't really agree with your takeaway on this. I don't think the bill has much teeth. And I think the bill could actually go the other way. The bill can be used both ways. It could be used, yes, to push maybe a trans agenda and hurt people. Could also use the flip, though. A therapist could also flip it. So it might be good. Never heard a word. They did not like my take on that. Yeah. But if that was that was my takeaway of it, you know? So more people, I think, need to engage with that. But but it's okay to change your mind. I have changed my mind many times over my life. That's another thing we see in our culture, right? This idea that you can't change your mind or else you're you're you're you're a flip-flopper, you're waffling, you're on the fence, like pick a side. It's like, well, you know, being on the fence isn't such a bad idea a lot of times. It's better than going over to one side and shooting someone in the face, say, doing don't go to one side and do something horrible before you have all the information.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. I think that a lot of people they form opinions when they don't have enough information to have an opinion.
SPEAKER_01It's just it's all regurgitation of the same shit. I can't tell you how is how frustrating it is as, you know, as a voting Democrat, and I still will vote Democrat because it's my only fucking choice, because I'm not a one one topic voter. I take the whole thing into consideration when I vote. But it is so frustrating to see, you know, liberals, democrats, progressives, whatever you want to call them, regurgitate the same bullshit over and over and over again, and you go, you're just doing talking points. You can't I mean, think about it for fuck's sake. Think about it. If someone brings an argument to you, think about it and and look at the information they're offering. Why not look at the information they're offering, even if you think they're wrong? I've done that. I've gone to Republican events, luncheons, and stuff where they discuss things because someone can say, oh, they're bigots, they're horrible, they're pieces of shit. You go there and you realize, well, you know, they're not bad people necessarily. However, I don't agree with what they're talking. I think they're talking out their ass. And I think that there's actual proof to prove they're wrong. You know what I mean? I think there's statistics, crime statistics, and everything to kind of prove they're probably wrong. But I'm not, but like, why that's a good approach, right? Come in with a good argument and have something to talk about and see if you guys can't land on some actual facts instead of one just saying one thing and one saying the other and each calling each other assholes. And we see the same problem in the lesbian community, the same problem in the gay community or the let's say the LGBT community. It's the same fucking problem in there.
SPEAKER_00It's the same fucking problem. And but I do think that like, and this is full full circle, back to like why lesbian spaces matter. I think that we would have less of this of less lesbians attacking each other, because that's what I find happens a lot, is that some some of the bigger, biggest pushers, some of the biggest pushers for homophobic rhetoric are lesbians themselves. And that is why I just think we need to separate from the G B T Q plus. I think lesbians, we just only we we have very specific interests and only we can advocate for them. And I think that it's okay for us to argue amongst ourselves. I think we can argue amongst ourselves, but we shouldn't be attacking each other, defending other people. Well, I think we should have always done that. I think we should be on the same team because we have the most to lose because we are women.
SPEAKER_01But there, but there, but there are lesbians out there. There are women out there who don't believe that. And I that's why I get it. I get it. Yeah. That's when we first started this conversation. I said, if you're the kind if you're the l the kind of lesbian that doesn't think there's any difference between a trans woman and a lesbian or trans woman, then they're not a lesbian.
SPEAKER_00If if a man might still be a lesbian. If a lesbian genuinely would go and and is capable of having feelings for for some like the opposite sex, they're not a lesbian. I'm sorry. They're not a lesbian.
SPEAKER_01Well, if they have actual feelings, I would say I agree with you. However, I think lesbians are, especially young lesbians, are pressured into. I've known some that were pressured into having a lot of people.
SPEAKER_00I think what happens though is a lot of those lesbians, they peak. I'm gonna be on a lot from what I'm seeing online, a lot of those a lot of these lesbians peak because they realize holy fucking shit. This is a dude. Holy fucking shit. This is rape culture. I have been raped. Like I have been coursed into this r relationship with the opposite sex. I actually find that a lot of lesbians who actually go down that path, they peak. They peak come out, they come out hard, right?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_00No, but it's sad. It's sad because they cry and I know they're it's devastating.
SPEAKER_01And the the lesbians that I spoke to who went down that path, they were trans identified themselves, right? So it gets much more complicated because you know, they're believing that they're really men. And then they're and if you if you believe you're really a man, then you have to believe that he's really a woman. And then, you know, it all just kind of goes out the window there. And then also, you know, within I would say within queer trans culture, there is really this push to not have a sexuality. There really is this this the moral thing to do is to be open to having sex with anybody. That's the moral thing to do.
SPEAKER_00As I said, it's homophobic and it's heterophobic. Like, you know, most people, you know, and it's not a preference. I don't have a preference, I'm just gay. Like, you know, it's not a preference. I'm just I'm just gay. But what I would say is that I think that this, you know, trans men are men, trans women are women is actually very transphobic when you think about it. Because they they should be like, I think the only way trans works, I think the only truly way trans works is if you are able to say, look, I am a biological female. Like you have to accept that I am a vi biological female, but this is how I want to look and this is how I want to present, and this is what makes me happy. Like you have to be okay with the fact that you are female, right?
SPEAKER_01This reminds me of like, because we were talking about therapy a while ago, and I this reminds me of the other problem where I think the therapeutic community is dropping the ball is honesty when someone wants to transition, right? It's like fine, if someone wants an adult wants to transition, but is a therapist doing their due diligence to to be understand that that person is ready for the reality of what that means? Cause I have to tell you I was not ready for the reality of what that meant. Because you you are very much in your head, at least I was. My own personal experience was I was very much in my head and I was very much in the in the transition. Bubble and we're all telling each other the same magical things, and then you get out there in reality and it slaps you in the fucking face and you go, Wow, I was not prepared for the reality of this, you know. But I agree with you. I agree with you. If you know someone wants to, you know, transition and present that way and live that way, that's fine. But I really, I really would like them to be honest about their sex. And when it comes to say lesbian spaces, I'm okay with trans men being in lesbian spaces if they're homosexual. They're women, same same, still female, they're homosexual.
SPEAKER_00That's how I'm fine with them being there. As long as they're not trying to peddle the that stuff, that's lesbians. That's the problem, is that a problem? If the problem is, is if this is what you're believing, if you're trying to, if you're gonna come and bring to lesbians, hey, you're transphobic if you're you want to date the opposite sex. I'm sorry, that person doesn't belong.
SPEAKER_01And I would also say that it becomes a problem when they try to recruit too, when they try to tell you you're trans or when they try to act like that's what all lies are. They aren't respectful of other people's stuff, you know.
SPEAKER_00The peer pressure. Yeah. Like when I was growing when I was in the party sick circuit, I don't think it was that bad. I think it it was definitely there, but it definitely ratcheted up, especially over the pandemic. It's super ratcheted up, and it's like ever almost every single androgynist or butch lesbian I used to know has decided to start taking tea. And it's just like, I don't know, man.
SPEAKER_01It's troubling because it is a social contagion, even among adults. It's a social contagion. And so that that that always made me wary of including transidentified females just because of that. But I also don't want to exclude them because they are female homosexuals. And also from my own experience, I know that there was times where I missed being with lesbians, but I wasn't ready to like let go of the trans identity yet. And I think being invited into lesbian spaces probably would have helped me to like re-engage with my like lesbian female identity and get out of identifying as trans maybe sooner. I also just finished reading Jesse's book.
SPEAKER_00And and yeah, Jesse speaks about that a little, going to a lesbian party and you know saying, hey, like, I want to be a lesbian. I just want to be a lesbian, right? So I don't know. So that's what like I don't think it's about trans exclusive. Everybody wants to say trans exclusive. It's not about that, it's about sex. So trans trans identifying females, in my opinion, they do belong. They do belong. They do belong.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. But this absolutely whether she wants me, once whether she wants me to b call her sister or not, she is my sister.
SPEAKER_00They're female and they're homosexual. As long as you're a female homosexual, right? Yeah. It is a lesbian experience. And I even think going down the trans pipeline is a les a very lesbian experience a lot of the times.
SPEAKER_01Well, a lot of lesbians have done it, so I would say yes. I would say at this point it is a definite, especially a butch or stud lesbian experience, since most of us that went down the line were more masculine to begin with.
SPEAKER_00I find it's very much like a butch experience. I find that if you're a mixed race like myself, or if it's that you grew up around a lot of white people and you're a stud, you're more likely to probably transition. But if you're not like if your your crowd and everything is more black, I actually find that the studs who are very entrenched in black culture, they're not interested in transitioning. They're like, no, I dress like this, but I'm a female, I'm a woman. Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_01No, I that seems I I can't you'd speak better on it than I would, but that seems to be what I saw too, generally speaking about it.
SPEAKER_00It's something that I've noticed very interesting.
SPEAKER_01A lot more white women doing it, a lot more butch women doing it than yeah. I think it's it did seem to run more in white culture, uh at least from my perspective, which has been about ten years ago at this point.
SPEAKER_00White and Asian, I find. And then I think what people are.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I did I did know I did know quite a few Asian detransitioners. Although interesting, actually, I say quite a few, but in the groups I was running in, if you came across like, you know, three out of ten, that was quite a few. Um like if you had a group of 10 detransitioners and three of them were Asian, that's a decently high like percentage for that. All the ones I knew though, they all had a history, they all were adopted. They all were adopted from an from actually their native country. They were one of those Oh. Yeah. And I almost think that that had more to do with their transition than anything else. You know what I mean? Like that that feeling of not belonging, that feeling of being torn from your culture and maybe, you know, ending up they all ended up with white people. And so I don't know. It was just an interesting thing I I saw. I was like, huh, that's fascinating. Humans are just so complex.
SPEAKER_00And that's why I just think that is.
SPEAKER_01We are complex, but predictable.
SPEAKER_00Complex with prediction.
SPEAKER_01No, but think about it. Psychology wouldn't work if we weren't predictable. And psychology generally works. Therapy generally works. You can understand even philosophy, it's all based off of seeing how human patterns and how humans behave. It works if you could actually ask questions, though.
SPEAKER_00Well, that's true. It's new affirmation. That's the problem I see is that therapy is just failing people because it's not getting to the root.
SPEAKER_01It's not why they stopped asking why. Why, why, why? Why is such an important question. Always ask why. Kids ask why all the time, and we give them shit for it. But man, that is a core human thing that should be encouraged. Ask those why questions and get a good answer. I want to just touch on this a little bit. I do think that lesbians, the the reason most lesbians support this inclusion of men in in will lesbian spaces is because of this idea of being nice, right? You have to be nice at all costs. And I the whole cult of nice. And I read this to you before we started recording, but I'm gonna read you this basically what the cult of nice means. So it's a cultural and religious critique describing a shallow social habit or pressure where people prioritize surface-level politeness, comfort, and conflict avoidance over deeper truth, moral clarity, or genuine compassion. And I think that fits the progressive movement to a T at this point. It's all about the cult of nice. It's about being nice, not hurting people's feelings, but not about truth, not about honesty, not about critical thinking. And so I think a lot of lesbians are caught in this cult of nice. They think they have to be nice at all costs that being nice is the most important thing in the world and not truth, not honesty, not boundaries. Yeah, cult of nice also is cult of fake. That's what it is. It's a cult of the city. I know, I agree, I agree, but I think so much of our culture has gone that way, especially progressive culture.
SPEAKER_00No, I I totally get it. I totally get it because you know, I think even with me, sometimes it's like, do you lie? Is the nice nicer way to do things is lie, or is it or is it better to tell the truth? And, you know, if you asked me this question a year ago, I probably would have said, you know, it's better to lie sometimes. You know, whereas right now I I I I think that actually real compassion and real like to really show you care is to be truthful.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_01And being truthful also means expressing your own beliefs as well. I'm truthful in my beliefs. You don't have to agree with me, but also I would prefer you not vilify me either. Vilifying people you disagree with is a big fucking problem too.
SPEAKER_00It's a really big problem. And what what's really funny because I remember I found out there were a few of my family members who were Trumpers. Keep in mind, we are in Canada. So, you know, when he got re-elected, I was so upset that, you know, I just like took a day off and I was playing video games all day or something. I just didn't want to interact with anything other than like a fake world because I was just so genuinely upset that Trump won in the US, even though I don't even live in the fucking US. But I think actually my my my aversion to Trump had more to do with he's bad for the whole world than he's bad for Canada. So, you know, it wasn't all of this like social justice things. It was just like we are gonna get World War III. That that's actually where I was at, right? That that was my form of Trump derangement syndrome, is that I just felt that he's gonna ruin the world and make my life more difficult. But I remember finding out that some of my my my my cousins were were Trumpers, and I was like, I can't talk to Trumpers. No discussion, you and I like no. And I cut like I didn't actually cut them off because literally half a year later, I started questioning myself and my beliefs. I started learning a little bit more about woke and whatever. And I was like, I'm somebody I realized that has I've been taking a no-debate approach. When did I become somebody who became no, I'm not gonna have a debate on this? Right. So even myself and I like to think that I'm somebody who's very open and everything. For a short period of time, I was being radicalized towards I'm not gonna have a a debate right and wrong, black and white, this is how it is.
SPEAKER_01We we've all been radicalized. And we have to ask who did it with the purpose. Why is it how why is it happening? Because it is it is sowing chaos. I think the purpose is to sow chaos and so that the people underneath can get what they want. Yeah. So yeah, to sum up, I think that lesbian spaces I think are super important and they're they're very important to keep strictly for lesbians and by lesbians are female homosexuals. And I think once you once you start diluting that down, you end up getting nothing. Absolutely nothing. Nothing. You get nothing. Because it's it's that's just if you want to break it down, that's science. You take a substance, you keep adding water to it, pretty soon that's not gonna exist anymore. And I see that's what's happening now, right? With this all-inclusion idea that everybody has to be included in everything. Everybody needs to be included in lesbian spaces. Well, now everybody's there and it's not a lesbian space anymore.
SPEAKER_00It's not a lesbian space. And we see this with language as well, which I actually think is incredibly dangerous. I started this whole anti-umbrella terms, like, you know, I I think umbrella terms can be helpful, but I also think they can be harmful. And with this whole trying to re-identify lesbian as non-man loving non-man, I was I freaked the fuck out. What the fuck is a non- what the fuck is a non-man? It's the most dehumanizing thing. I no, I'm not a non-man, I'm a woman, right?
SPEAKER_01That that's what piqued you.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so we're seeing it to language as well. And if you take a word like lesbian and it has a very firm definition, right? It is a it is a label about women, it is a a label about exclusive same-sex attraction to women. Women is the the root of lesbian. Yeah, you remove women from lesbianism, to your point, you have nothing. You start adding to this definition that had a very specific cause, it means nothing anymore. You've you've you've you've made it so that lesbianism actually doesn't exist anymore.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And and what what happens if there's no lesbian space? Well, the importance of lesbian space is to find other lesbians to not only befriend, but honestly, to find partners and to have sex with women. That's the point. That is the fucking point. And I think maybe we've become a little too relaxed about that. We've we've or been shy about it. It's like, no, I want if I was single, I would want a lesbian space because I want to find women who want to fuck me and I want to fuck them. That's the point. And maybe it leads to relationship. That's great too. But that's the fucking point. I can walk into a bar and see a woman I think is hot and know I can go up to her and you know, hit on her, ask for buy her, drink, whatever, talk to her, and not be like, is she gay? Is she not gay? Am I gonna get my ass kicked? Is her boyfriend gonna come up and do something weird? Which is the situation if you're just out in the world not knowing who's gay and who's not. You gotta make these guessing games. That's why those spaces were so important and valuable, right? Lesbian bars were awesome. You could go into a lesbian bar and no, you were in a lesbian fucking bar.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. And now the lesbian bars aren't fucking lesbian bars. I don't know if you you know about the last stitch bar. That was, in my opinion, they're calling a lesbian bar. It's not a lesbian.
SPEAKER_01No, that was was that the one that was such a fucking massive.
SPEAKER_00The COVID conscious oh, yes, oh geez. They want to call it a COVID conscious lesbian bar, and I'm just like, nothing but.
SPEAKER_01But it has more problems than the fact that it wasn't a lesbian bar.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_00Like, I'm just like, this is not a lesbian bar. This is this is the the queer bar, if you want to call it something. Yeah, but it's not a lesbian bar. But having spaces is important because at the end of the day, I think like, yeah, we just need to actually distill it down to what is the purpose of a lesbian space and what is the purpose of a lesbian bar. If you're single, it is to find a mate. Yeah. That is the point. That's that's the point. If it's that you're not single, let's say you you have a partner, it's likely you're looking for like-minded friends. Yeah. Because friendship and companionship is very important, and you're looking for people who share your lived experience. And what I could say is that it is so important. Like mating and like finding people is so important because for human beings, like we are not meant to be alone, I don't think. There's some people who do well with solidarity, most of us cannot. And to a degree, we are talking about psychology. I do believe there is a hierarchy of needs. And I do think that if your base needs aren't met, you're not going to be able to become maybe the person you want to be. And at the bottom, right, like there's what food, shelter, you know, safety. But I think the next layer, if I recall correctly, is like companionship.
SPEAKER_01And so it's so love is super important with people, with humans. Well, every all, even animals, we see that baby animals that don't get the care they need end up more stressed out and just don't do well as adults.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. I think that as a human being, you don't start leveling up if you don't have love. I agree. Right? And how do we level up and find love if we can't have find lesbian spaces? Exactly. I mean, you can't even do the apps either. The apps are all inclusive as well. So my god, her did you hear about what the CEO said? The her app? I'm so upset. I'm sure there's no such thing as a real lesbian. No such thing as a you know, and they've been booting off lesbians from her. Like, I know.
SPEAKER_01And the thing is, it's like that look look, I'm fine. Here's another example. I'm okay if they want to include men on that site, but allow women to put in their profile that they are not interested. Allow them to say, I am only interested in women-born women. Yeah, like well stop. What's wrong? No, they get booted for that shit.
SPEAKER_00They get booted for being a lesbian. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03So fucking ridiculous.
SPEAKER_00It's so fucking ridiculous. And I just look at this pandering. Like, who who do they think they're acting like circulating lies like to this grand scale that lesbians will actually date the opposite sex? Like a a lie like this, I'm sorry, it's it's a lie. It's like saying two plus two equals three. I'm sorry, it's a fucking lie.
SPEAKER_01Lesbians are not gonna fucking date the opposite sex unless we're coursed into Do these people who say this shit think that straight men don't exist and straight women don't exist? Do they think bisexuals don't exist? I mean, like what genuine none of it exists? I genuinely think so.
SPEAKER_00They're trying to push this the sexuality is fluid for every one bullshit. And it's like, no, there's there I would say that I I genuinely feel that most people are a degree of bisexual. I do do like I think that like most people maybe are a little bit of a degree of bisexual, you know, but there even in that there's a spectrum, right? But heterosexuals exist, homosexuals exist, and bisexuals exist. What is with all this erasure? Exactly.
SPEAKER_01So lesbian spaces are important. I hope we made our case. I think we made a good case for it, right? Even if you disagree with this, which if you do, I personally would love to hear you. Tell me why you disagree and why you think it's important if you're a lesbian. I I am not afraid to have those conversations.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I'm not afraid to have these conversations either. The way I see it is that I think we all can recognize that if black people wanted to have a cookout for just black people, it's fine. But anytime it has to do with gay men or lesbians, have you noticed this? Anytimes it's about gay men or lesbians, it it's okay if everybody's inserted. It is the same thing even with uh novels, right? Like books. Let's say we had a a white person writing a story about a black person and it's just trauma porn. Everybody would just be up in arms, right? But it's okay, though, for people who aren't gay to write trauma porn consistently. Like it's their whole author career, right? To write about lesbians and gay men.
SPEAKER_01That's a perfect that's another perfect example of the hypocrisy of on the left is this, I is this like they they all of this, like don't uh don't appropriate, like you know, appropriate, don't culturally appropriate. Oh my god, it's the worst thing you can do, you know, which I I agree. I don't think people should culturally appropriate. I agree with that. But like, oh blah, blah, blah. Except when it comes to women, except when it comes to lesbians and gay men. Lesbians and gay men like, wait a minute, wait a minute here. I thought appropriating was fucked up. So it, but it's okay for some pre some people to do it and not other people to do it. What the fuck? I don't know. Anyways, I think we made a good case. Um, I hope, I hope the women liked liked this episode.
SPEAKER_00So too. Good talking, Carol.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it was great talking to you again.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, have a good one.
SPEAKER_01You too.
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Lesbian Project Podcast
The Lesbian Project Podcast
Sex Matters
Sex Matters